10
Nov 2015
Internet Governance Forum 2015: Five More Sessions with I&J
I&J contributed
November 22, 2015
Engaging in the UN Internet Governance Forum
The Internet & Jurisdiction Project participated in the Internet Governance Forum convened by the United Nations on November 10 – 13, 2015, in Joao Pessoa, Brazil, where it organized the workshop “Transnational due process: A case study in multi-stakeholder cooperation”. In addition to the workshop convened by Internet & Jurisdiction, Bertrand de la Chapelle and Paul Fehlinger were invited as speakers at five different sessions.
Main Session — Setting the Scene
Bertrand de la Chapelle was a speaker at the Setting the Scene session, organized to provide an overview of hot topics of the eight main sessions of the Internet Governance Forum 2015. Bertrand de La Chapelle was selected to speak about the main theme, "Cybersecurity and Trust." He observed that the jurisdiction issue has now become a main topic on the global Internet Governance agenda and called for multistakeholder action to preserve the global character of the Internet. Mr. La Chapelle's speech starts below:
Bertrand de La Chapelle speaks about cybersecurity and trust in the Setting the Scene session of the 2015 IGF.
Participants
Bertrand de La Chapelle
DirectorInternet & Jurisdiction
Hasnanul Haq Inu
Minister of ICTBangladesh
Rahul Gosain
Director, IRSMEIndian, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology
Vint Cerf
Vice President and Chief Internet EvangelistByron Holland
President and CEOCanadian Internet Registry Authority (CIRA)
Peter Major
Working Group ChairUN Commission on Science and Technology for Development
Paul Mitchell
Senior Director, Tech PolicyMicrosoft
Constance Bommelaer
Senior Director, Global Internet PolicyISOC
Workshop — Implementing Core Principles in the Digital Age
The governments of Brazil and Germany invited Bertrand de La Chapelle to speak about how to move key Internet Governance principles moving forward. The session focused on the question of how to implement core principles like democracy, accountability, human rights and due process in Internet Governance. Mr. La Chapelle stressed the need for developing cooperation mechanisms between the different stakeholders to operationalize core principles in working policy frameworks.
We need to develop procedures so that the laws can coexist in the different spaces. They need to guarantee due process across borders.
Highlighting the need to implement operational solutions to ensure human rights principles and the global character of the Internet.
Participants
Anriette Esterhuysen
Executive DirectorAssociation for Progressive Communications
Bertrand de La Chapelle
DirectorInternet & Jurisdiction
David Kaye
UN Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and ExpressionUnited Nations
Eileen Donahoe
Director of Global AffairsHuman Rights Watch
Frida Orring
European External Action Service
Joana Varon
Project CoordinatorCTS Getulio Vargas Foundation
Joseph Cannataci
Special Rapporteur for the Right to PrivacyUnited Nations
Marietje Schaake
MemberEuropean Parliament
Mishi Choudhary
Legal DirectorSoftware Freedom Law Center
Moez Chakchouk
Tunisian Postal ServiceTunisia
Nanjira Sambuli
iHub Kenia
Niels ten Oever
Head, DigitalArticle 19
Nnenna Nwakanma
Africa Regional CoordinatorWorld Wide Web Foundation
Nora Abusitta
ICANN
Sheetal Kumar
Global Partners Digital
Thiago Tavares
PresidentSaferNet
Thomas Fitschen
Ambassador and Director for the United Nations, International Cyber Policy and CounterterrorismGermany, Federal Foreign Office
Workshop — When Governments Hit "Like" on the War on Terror
Paul Fehlinger was invited to speak at the workshop titled When Governments hit ‘Like’ on the War on Terror. The workshop revisited efforts in various countries to combat terrorism online and analyzed the impact of adopted measures on human rights. Mr. Fehlinger emphasized the importance of multistakeholder cooperation to develop appropriate and balanced solutions that can work in the transnational online environment:
The challenge of terrorist content online needs to be addressed in a multistakeholder manner.
Paul Fehlinger discussing the mutual nature of the jurisdictional challenge, and how it affects all stakeholders simultaneously.
Participants
Anja Mihr
Utrecht University
Ephraim Kenyanito
Access
Frank La Rue
Assistant Director-General for Communication and InformationUNESCO
Gabrielle Guillemin
Senior Legal OfficerArticle 19
Melody Patry
Index on Censorship
Paul Fehlinger
ManagerInternet & Jurisdiction
Workshop — Building Internet Observatories: Approaches and Challenges
For the first time, leading Observatories in the Internet Governance space gathered at the Internet Governance Forum. Paul Fehlinger stressed the historic nature of this gathering. The I&J Observatory that was launched in 2012 to provide expert-input into the Internet & Jurisdiction process and is one of the longest-running Observatories in the Internet Governance landscape.
The workshop posed the question how different Internet Observatory projects can create synergies, avoid duplication of efforts, and foster cooperation in order to positively impact capacity-building, education, and policy-making in Internet Governance. Mr. Fehlinger stressed the need to work together to take advantage of the data gathered by the various observatories to ensure the Internet governance debate moves ahead on the basis of solid evidence.
This workshop is a sign of the maturity of the ecosystem of Internet governance as such. I want to highlight the real need and benefit is to enable what we, at the Internet & Jurisdiction Project, call evidence-based policy innovation, so that the debates on Internet Governance are inspired and informed by evidence.
Paul Fehlinger describes the way that the I&J Observatory facilitates evidence-based dialogues in the Internet & Jurisdiction policy process.
Participants
Arne Hintz
Mapping Global Media Policy
Carlos Affonso Souza
DirectorInstitute for Technology and Society Rio
Giancarlo Frosio
Stanford University, Center for Internet and Society
Kasia Jakimowicz
Global Internet Policy Observatory
Kelli Kim
Open Net Korea
Nicolau Reinhard
University of São Paulo
Omar Kaminski
Brazilian Marco Civil Observatory
Paul Fehlinger
ManagerInternet & Jurisdiction
Stefaan Verhulst
DirectorThe GovLab at NYU
Susan Chambers
US Department of Commerce NTIA
Tereza Horejsova
Geneva Internet Platform
Session — Birds of a Feather: A Network of Virtual Working Spaces for Internet Governance?
On November 13, 2015, Bertrand de La Chapelle and Paul Fehlinger moderated a Birds of a Feather (BoF) meeting, an innovative format to place new issues on the Internet Governance agenda. This short session titled A network of virtual working spaces for Internet Governance? gathered actors interested in exploring the feasibility of building a network of high-performance connected virtual meeting spaces for Internet Governance working groups. It explored how to best take advantage of the dramatic lowering in costs of bandwidth, flat panel displays, and image compression. The session covered how a joint effort by technology providers, international organizations, and civil society networks could help build a series of connected local hubs providing high-capacity teleconferencing for use by multistakeholder initiatives. Such hubs could also be leveraged to facilitate remote participation in numerous meetings, including the Internet Governance forum.
Participants
James Wood
Senior Director Strategic CommunicationsISoc
Michael Nelson
Public Policy DirectorCloudFlare
Anne Carblanc
Head, Digital Economy Policy DivisionOECD
Robert Pepper
Vice-President Global Technology PolicyCISCO
Bertrand de La Chapelle
DirectorInternet & Jurisdiction
Engaging in the UN Internet Governance Forum
The Internet & Jurisdiction Project participated in the Internet Governance Forum convened by the United Nations on November 10 – 13, 2015, in Joao Pessoa, Brazil, where it organized the workshop “Transnational due process: A case study in multi-stakeholder cooperation”. In addition to the workshop convened by Internet & Jurisdiction, Bertrand de la Chapelle and Paul Fehlinger were invited as speakers at five different sessions.
Main Session — Setting the Scene
Bertrand de la Chapelle was a speaker at the Setting the Scene session, organized to provide an overview of hot topics of the eight main sessions of the Internet Governance Forum 2015. Bertrand de La Chapelle was selected to speak about the main theme, "Cybersecurity and Trust." He observed that the jurisdiction issue has now become a main topic on the global Internet Governance agenda and called for multistakeholder action to preserve the global character of the Internet. Mr. La Chapelle's speech starts below:
Bertrand de La Chapelle speaks about cybersecurity and trust in the Setting the Scene session of the 2015 IGF.
Participants
Bertrand de La Chapelle
DirectorInternet & Jurisdiction
Hasnanul Haq Inu
Minister of ICTBangladesh
Rahul Gosain
Director, IRSMEIndian, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology
Vint Cerf
Vice President and Chief Internet EvangelistByron Holland
President and CEOCanadian Internet Registry Authority (CIRA)
Peter Major
Working Group ChairUN Commission on Science and Technology for Development
Paul Mitchell
Senior Director, Tech PolicyMicrosoft
Constance Bommelaer
Senior Director, Global Internet PolicyISOC
Workshop — Implementing Core Principles in the Digital Age
The governments of Brazil and Germany invited Bertrand de La Chapelle to speak about how to move key Internet Governance principles moving forward. The session focused on the question of how to implement core principles like democracy, accountability, human rights and due process in Internet Governance. Mr. La Chapelle stressed the need for developing cooperation mechanisms between the different stakeholders to operationalize core principles in working policy frameworks.
We need to develop procedures so that the laws can coexist in the different spaces. They need to guarantee due process across borders.
Highlighting the need to implement operational solutions to ensure human rights principles and the global character of the Internet.
Participants
Anriette Esterhuysen
Executive DirectorAssociation for Progressive Communications
Bertrand de La Chapelle
DirectorInternet & Jurisdiction
David Kaye
UN Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and ExpressionUnited Nations
Eileen Donahoe
Director of Global AffairsHuman Rights Watch
Frida Orring
European External Action Service
Joana Varon
Project CoordinatorCTS Getulio Vargas Foundation
Joseph Cannataci
Special Rapporteur for the Right to PrivacyUnited Nations
Marietje Schaake
MemberEuropean Parliament
Mishi Choudhary
Legal DirectorSoftware Freedom Law Center
Moez Chakchouk
Tunisian Postal ServiceTunisia
Nanjira Sambuli
iHub Kenia
Niels ten Oever
Head, DigitalArticle 19
Nnenna Nwakanma
Africa Regional CoordinatorWorld Wide Web Foundation
Nora Abusitta
ICANN
Sheetal Kumar
Global Partners Digital
Thiago Tavares
PresidentSaferNet
Thomas Fitschen
Ambassador and Director for the United Nations, International Cyber Policy and CounterterrorismGermany, Federal Foreign Office
Workshop — When Governments Hit "Like" on the War on Terror
Paul Fehlinger was invited to speak at the workshop titled When Governments hit ‘Like’ on the War on Terror. The workshop revisited efforts in various countries to combat terrorism online and analyzed the impact of adopted measures on human rights. Mr. Fehlinger emphasized the importance of multistakeholder cooperation to develop appropriate and balanced solutions that can work in the transnational online environment:
The challenge of terrorist content online needs to be addressed in a multistakeholder manner.
Paul Fehlinger discussing the mutual nature of the jurisdictional challenge, and how it affects all stakeholders simultaneously.
Participants
Anja Mihr
Utrecht University
Ephraim Kenyanito
Access
Frank La Rue
Assistant Director-General for Communication and InformationUNESCO
Gabrielle Guillemin
Senior Legal OfficerArticle 19
Melody Patry
Index on Censorship
Paul Fehlinger
ManagerInternet & Jurisdiction
Workshop — Building Internet Observatories: Approaches and Challenges
For the first time, leading Observatories in the Internet Governance space gathered at the Internet Governance Forum. Paul Fehlinger stressed the historic nature of this gathering. The I&J Observatory that was launched in 2012 to provide expert-input into the Internet & Jurisdiction process and is one of the longest-running Observatories in the Internet Governance landscape.
The workshop posed the question how different Internet Observatory projects can create synergies, avoid duplication of efforts, and foster cooperation in order to positively impact capacity-building, education, and policy-making in Internet Governance. Mr. Fehlinger stressed the need to work together to take advantage of the data gathered by the various observatories to ensure the Internet governance debate moves ahead on the basis of solid evidence.
This workshop is a sign of the maturity of the ecosystem of Internet governance as such. I want to highlight the real need and benefit is to enable what we, at the Internet & Jurisdiction Project, call evidence-based policy innovation, so that the debates on Internet Governance are inspired and informed by evidence.
Paul Fehlinger describes the way that the I&J Observatory facilitates evidence-based dialogues in the Internet & Jurisdiction policy process.
Participants
Arne Hintz
Mapping Global Media Policy
Carlos Affonso Souza
DirectorInstitute for Technology and Society Rio
Giancarlo Frosio
Stanford University, Center for Internet and Society
Kasia Jakimowicz
Global Internet Policy Observatory
Kelli Kim
Open Net Korea
Nicolau Reinhard
University of São Paulo
Omar Kaminski
Brazilian Marco Civil Observatory
Paul Fehlinger
ManagerInternet & Jurisdiction
Stefaan Verhulst
DirectorThe GovLab at NYU
Susan Chambers
US Department of Commerce NTIA
Tereza Horejsova
Geneva Internet Platform
Session — Birds of a Feather: A Network of Virtual Working Spaces for Internet Governance?
On November 13, 2015, Bertrand de La Chapelle and Paul Fehlinger moderated a Birds of a Feather (BoF) meeting, an innovative format to place new issues on the Internet Governance agenda. This short session titled A network of virtual working spaces for Internet Governance? gathered actors interested in exploring the feasibility of building a network of high-performance connected virtual meeting spaces for Internet Governance working groups. It explored how to best take advantage of the dramatic lowering in costs of bandwidth, flat panel displays, and image compression. The session covered how a joint effort by technology providers, international organizations, and civil society networks could help build a series of connected local hubs providing high-capacity teleconferencing for use by multistakeholder initiatives. Such hubs could also be leveraged to facilitate remote participation in numerous meetings, including the Internet Governance forum.
Participants
James Wood
Senior Director Strategic CommunicationsISoc
Michael Nelson
Public Policy DirectorCloudFlare
Anne Carblanc
Head, Digital Economy Policy DivisionOECD
Robert Pepper
Vice-President Global Technology PolicyCISCO
Bertrand de La Chapelle
DirectorInternet & Jurisdiction